Real numbers · Definition
Ordered field
Before talking about limits we need a setting where adding, multiplying and comparing behave as expected; the ordered field fixes those rules.
Definition
An ordered field is a field \(F\) with a total order \(<\) compatible with addition and with multiplication by positive elements.
The usual rules for inequalities follow from the axioms. Trichotomy holds (for each pair \(a,b\) exactly one of \(a<b\), \(a=b\), \(a>b\) is true), the same element can be added to both sides, and one can multiply by a positive element. Multiplying by a negative element reverses the direction: from \(-3<2\) we get \(12>-8\) after multiplying by \(-4\).
A basic result is that \(a^2\ge0\) for every \(a\), hence \(1=1^2>0\). This has strong consequences: \(\mathbb C\) cannot be ordered because \(i^2=-1<0\), and no finite field \(\mathbb Z/p\) can be, since the sum \(1+\cdots+1\) of \(p\) terms would be positive yet equals \(0\).
The rationals \(\mathbb Q\) and the reals \(\mathbb R\) are ordered fields, and so is \(\mathbb Q(\sqrt2)\). So order properties do not distinguish \(\mathbb R\) from \(\mathbb Q\): what separates them is completeness, introduced through the supremum and the completeness axiom.
A common mistake is to use \(a<b\Rightarrow a^2<b^2\) carelessly; it only holds if \(0\le a<b\). With \(-3<2\) it fails, since \(9>4\).
Think about it
Prove that in an ordered field, if \(a>0\) then \(1/a>0\).
If \(1/a<0\), multiplying by \(a>0\) would give \(1<0\), contradicting \(1>0\). Since \(1/a\ne0\), it must be \(1/a>0\).
Is there an ordered field with exactly 3 elements?
No: in \(\mathbb Z/3\) we would have \(1+1+1=0\), but in an ordered field that sum is positive.
Exercises 10
- If \(a<b\) and \(c<0\) in an ordered field, what holds?
- Which of these sets, with the usual operations and order, is not an ordered field?
- Which statement is true in every ordered field \(F\)?
- If \(a<b\) in an ordered field, which inequality follows?
- Multiply the inequality \(-3<2\) by \(-4\). What results?
- If \(0<a<b\), which is true?
- For \(a,b\) in an ordered field, how many of \(a<b\), \(a=b\), \(a>b\) are true?
- If \(0<a<b\) in an ordered field, how do \(a+b\) and \(2a\) compare?
- Why can the finite field \(\mathbb Z/p\) (\(p\) prime) not be made an ordered field?
- Why can \(\mathbb C\) not be an ordered field?
What comes next
References
- Stephen Abbott, Understanding Analysis, 2nd edition, Springer, 2015. §1.2
- Walter Rudin, Principles of Mathematical Analysis, 3rd edition, McGraw-Hill, 1976. Cap. 1, 1.5–1.18
- Robert G. Bartle, Donald R. Sherbert, Introduction to Real Analysis, 4th edition, Wiley, 2011. §2.1