Actions and Sylow theorems · Definition
p-group
Before you start you need to know
\(p\)-groups are the building blocks that the Sylow theorems use to recover the structure of any finite group.
Definition
A \(p\)-group is a finite group \(G\) whose order is a power \(p^n\), with \(n\ge1\), of a prime number \(p\).
A \(p\)-group can be defined in two equivalent ways: by its order, which is \(p^n\), or by its elements, since every element has order a power of \(p\). One direction comes from Lagrange (the order of each element divides \(p^n\)); the other is Cauchy's theorem, which guarantees an element of order \(q\) for each prime \(q\) dividing \(|G|\). Likewise, every subgroup and every quotient of a \(p\)-group is again a \(p\)-group.
The central property is that the center of a nontrivial \(p\)-group is nontrivial. Let \(G\) act on itself by conjugation: each orbit size divides \(p^n\), and the orbits of size \(1\) are the elements of the center; since \(p^n\) is a multiple of \(p\), so is \(|Z(G)|\), hence \(|Z(G)|\ge p\). More generally, if a \(p\)-group acts on a set \(X\), then \(|X|\equiv|X^G|\pmod p\), where \(X^G\) is the set of fixed points.
Guiding examples: \(\mathbb{Z}_{p^n}\), the groups \(\mathbb{Z}_p^k\) and the symmetry group of the square, of order \(8\), are \(p\)-groups. Groups of order \(p\) are cyclic, and those of order \(p^2\) are always abelian (cyclic or \(\mathbb{Z}_p\times\mathbb{Z}_p\)). At order \(p^3\) nonabelian groups already appear, so commutativity must not be assumed.
Typical mistake: thinking that a group whose order has several primes is a «\(p\)-group of some kind». A group of order \(12\) is not a \(p\)-group, even though it has \(2\)-subgroups and \(3\)-subgroups; those maximal subgroups are precisely the Sylow ones, the topic that follows.
Think about it
If \(G\) has order \(p^2\), why is \(G\) abelian?
The center has order \(p\) or \(p^2\). If it were \(p\), \(G/Z\) would be cyclic of order \(p\), which forces \(G\) to be abelian and \(Z=G\), a contradiction. Hence \(Z=G\).
Exercises 10
- Which of these groups is a \(2\)-group?
- In a group of order \(125\), which cannot be the order of an element?
- A subgroup of a group of order \(16\) cannot have order:
- Is \(\mathbb{Z}_{9}\times\mathbb{Z}_{3}\) a \(p\)-group? For which prime \(p\)?
- A group of order \(81\) has a subgroup of order \(9\). What is the index of that subgroup?
- For which primes \(p\) is a group of order \(12\) a \(p\)-group?
- A finite group has an element of order \(15\). Can it be a \(p\)-group?
- A group of order \(25\) acts on a set of \(11\) elements. What is the minimum number of fixed points?
- Select the true statement about a finite \(p\)-group \(G\).
- Which cannot be the order of the center of a group of order \(27\)?
What comes next
References
- David S. Dummit, Richard M. Foote, Abstract Algebra, 3rd edition, Wiley, 2004. §4.3
- John B. Fraleigh, A First Course in Abstract Algebra, 7th edition, Pearson, 2002. §36
- Joseph A. Gallian, Contemporary Abstract Algebra, 9th edition, Cengage, 2017. cap. 24